Automotive Reviews
Posts tagged subcompact
2004 Saturn ION
Jul 21st
For some reason, automotive journalists have always disliked the Saturn S-series. Ever since the brand was born in 1991, the little subcompact four-door sedans and two-door coupes have been criticized by the motoring press as being unambitious, poor performers, and downright dull.
Funny thing is, the lack of critical acclaim hasn’t hurt Saturn’s fortunes in the least. The lineup has expanded to include a larger sedan and wagon and just this year Saturn debuted its first sport-utility vehicle. It wasn’t that long ago that Saturn built its two-millionth car. With things so rosy, it was time for Saturn to go back to the drawing board on the car that began its tradition of repeated dissings by the media in the first place. Enter the new Saturn ION.
The ION replaced the bread-and-butter S-series in 2003, and it wasn’t an easy task. With the quantum leaps in quality and amenities made by subcompact Hondas and Toyotas in recent years, Saturn had to find a way to remain competitive, add some much-needed sizzle to the lineup, and retain its loyal buyers, all with the same car. Better yet, it appears that the ION succeeds at each of these goals. For 2004, the new car gets some interior tweaks and a high performance Red Line version of the coupe.
The first and most obvious improvement over Saturns of old is the design. The ION has shades of Infiniti and Oldsmobile in its new face, but it doesn’t copy anyone in particular. The swept-back look of the front end meets a vertical rear-door cutline for an interesting silhouette, and the tail is angular and tall. The 16″ wheels have an interesting cross-shaped hub. The three-door coupe has become a Quad Coupe, with a half-door (Saturn calls them “rear-access doors,” or RADs for short) on each side to improve access to the rear seat. It also has distinctive styling from the sedan. Plastic body panels attached to a steel spaceframe, a Saturn trademark, are used on both models. In addition to the striking design, ION takes personalization to new heights. The roof rail panels which arch over the windows from A-pillar to C-pillar are available in contrasting or matching colors from the factory, and additional panels can be purchased in a variety of patterns and colors and changed like cell-phone faces, according to the ION driver’s mood. Leopard, Blue Bubble, Silver Braid and Brushed Steel are just the first patterns available for 2003. Admit it; you’ve always wanted to put leopard spots on your car, just for a while, haven’t you?
There are more removable panels inside the ION. The trim surrounding the shifter, radio controls, and instrument pod can be swapped out to match the arch-panels outside the car. Don’t worry about getting bored of an overly quirky pattern; they pop in and out easily. Further distinguishing the interior, the instrument panel is centrally located. The Toyota ECHO also uses this gimmick. It’s not as disorienting as you’d expect; getting used to the gauges being in the center doesn’t take long. More distracting is the thick A-pillar, which can block forward visibility. The steering wheel is an unusual affair, with a large round center hub and relatively narrow diameter. It looks neat but we wish it were wider. The ION is well-appointed inside, and the CD player is MP3-ready. XM satellite radio is also available.
Under the hood is an all-new “Ecotec” 2.2 liter four-cylinder. GM plans to use this small engine in several car lines; it’s currently shared with the four-cylinder Saturn L-Series and the compact Chevy Cavalier and Pontiac Sunfire. With 140 horsepower on tap, it keeps up with traffic easily, but the Saturn is a commuter at heart. The little all-aluminum sixteen-valve engine is quiet and efficient, and meets Low Emissions Vehicle (LEV) standards. A clever noise-reducing innovation that most owners will likely never notice is the mounting of engine accessories such as the alternator and air conditioning compressor directly to the engine block, rather than using brackets that may transmit noise. Saturn isn’t alone in using a simplified accessory system, but it helps to keep the ION feeling more expensive than it is. The engine isn’t a powerhouse, but high-rpm street combat is anathema to Saturns anyway. The engine’s unwillingness to pump out the horses at high revs will be a moot point to most owners. A five-speed transmission built by Getrag is standard, and it’s a bit notchier than we’d like thanks to a cable-operated shifter. The five-speed automatic saps some power though, and we preferred the stick. Later in the year, the ION will share the VUE’s continuously variable transmission.
The suspension is more conventional. Struts are used up front, with a semi-independent torsion beam rear end. The torsion beams in the rear do more for improving space in the trunk than they do for ultimate handling performance. Nevertheless, the ION is decent over the road, and confident on the freeway thanks to a long wheelbase (compared to the competition) and a wide track. Balance is improved by mounting the battery in the trunk. Anti-lock brakes are optional.
Another thing most buyers won’t notice is the electric power steering. It feels no different from a conventional hydraulic system, but Saturn says that fuel economy is improved because the engine has one less pump to sap its power.
One of the happiest aspects of the new Saturn is the price. The sedan has an MSRP of $10,995, with three simple trim levels (called 1, 2 and 3) available. The ION1 is a stripped-out base model, but the sub-$14,000 ION 2 has air conditioning and a CD player standard. IONs can be optioned to rival the best competitors, too. Side-curtain airbags, a six-disc CD changer, auto-dim mirrors, and GM’s OnStar emergency service system are all available. It all adds up to one of the better small sedans available for 2003. Never thought you’d hear one of us car writers say that about a Saturn, did you?
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2004 Saturn ION.
Length: 184.5 in.
Width: 67.2 in.
Height: 57.4 in.
Wheelbase: 103.2 in.
Curb weight: 2766 lb.
Cargo space: 14.7 cu.ft.
Base price: $10,995 (sedan)
Engine: 2.2 liter 16-valve inline four-cylinder
Drivetrain: five-speed automatic, front-wheel drive
Horsepower: 140 @ 5800
Torque: 145 @ 4400
Fuel capacity: 13.5 gal.
Est. mileage: 24/32
2003 Pontiac Sunfire
Jul 21st
It may be the darling of rentacar agencies everywhere, but that doesn’t mean that Pontiac considers the compact Sunfire to be out of the game. The Sunfire soldiers into 2003 with a fresh redesign and an improved powerplant.
It’s the first significant visual update for the smallest Pontiac in recent memory, and it’s a welcome change. Cat’s-eye headlamps and prominent turn signals replace the Sunfire’s beaky nose. The grille has been enlarged as well, and the Sunfire’s new face makes it one of the more expressive Pontiacs of recent years. The rounded sedan body style remains more or less the same, with a nice selection of new three-spoke 15″ and 16″ wheels to choose from. Out back, the taillights have been enlarged and the rear end aspect simplified. Much of the excess cladding that Pontiac has become notorious for is absent. An unusual spoiler mounted at the bottom edge of the rear window is standard equipment. The freshened Sunfire stands out from both Enterprise Rentacar’s fleets and from its many subcompact Japanese competitors.
Inside, the orange gauges and gumdrop stereo buttons are familiar. New seat cloth patterns are wild and distinctive. A folding rear seat increases cargo capacity. The real changes aren’t as obvious. The standard single-CD sound system can be upgraded to an eight-speaker Monsoon system, or to XM satellite radio. General Motors’ OnStar “directions and connections” system is also available, offering emergency services at the touch of a button.
Under the hood, there’s a 2.2 liter four-cylinder engine that debuted last year as an option. The “Ecotec” engine is now standard on all Sunfires. It’s shared with the new Chevrolet Cavalier and Saturn ION as well. The Ecotec’s 140 horsepower is about the same as the previous engine; the big news is in smoothness. A stiffened block and oil pan and a cam cover designed to reduce noise transmission all go toward modernizing the Ecotec engine. The Sunfire’s new engine lacks the thrashy note and vibration issues that plagued the car for years. The smoother powerplant should make a world of difference. Buyers can choose a five-speed manual transmission or an optional four-speed automatic. We prefer the manual, which is produced by German transmission maker Getrag.
The Sunfire’s supension still has MacPherson struts up front and a somewhat archaic control arm and twist-beam rear. Handling can be called economy-car like rather than sporty. For getting around town it’s a handy enough system, but more sophisticated compacts like the Ford Focus and Honda Civic are more fun to drive. When the going gets slippery, the Enhanced Traction System is a part of the optional automatic transmission and limits wheelspin. Anti-lock brakes are also offered. Side airbags are available, making the Sunfire one of the few compact cars to offer them.
The Sunfire has always been aggressively priced, especially compared to Hondas and Toyotas which seem to get more expensive every year. The smallest Pontiac is offered in one trim level with option packages to boost the content level, and the bottom line is $15,180. Prices like that are normally attached to bargain-basement Korean cars. For that price, the Sunfire comes with air conditioning, daytime running lights, a rear window defroster and of course dual airbags.
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2003 Pontiac Sunfire.
Length: 182 in.
Width: 68.4 in.
Height: 53.0 in.
Wheelbase: 104.1 in.
Curb weight: 2606 lb.
Cargo space: 12.4 cu.ft.
Base price: $15,180
Engine: 2.2 liter DOHC inline four-cylinder
Drivetrain: five-speed manual transmission, front-wheel drive
Horsepower: 140 @ 5600
Torque: 150 @ 4000
Fuel capacity: 14.1 gal.
Est. mileage: 24/33
2003 MINI Cooper
Jul 21st
After an hour with the MINI Cooper I had made up my mind: they couldn’t have it back. The MINI people were just going to have to build another one to give to the next journalist, because this one was mine. I’d write them a check for any amount. I’d barricade myself in the garage with it if I had to. I wouldn’t be taken alive. The MINI and I could escape to Canada and start a new life for ourselves, on the run.
Was it simple holiday madness, or is the MINI really that good? In order to remain some shred of journalistic objectivity, I’m not going to answer that question, but let’s just say that it’s gotten a lot easier to answer when people ask me, “So what’s your favorite car, of the new ones you’ve driven?”
Let’s start from the beginning. The happy, cheeky little box of a car you see here is the all-new 2003 MINI Cooper. It’s spiritually descended from the British-built BMC Mini of the 1960s and 1970s, the revolutionary commuter turned pop-culture icon by movies like The Italian Job. The new MINI is built by BMW, however.
The result is immediately recognizable. The round headlights, stubby nose and tail, and squared-off roof are clear hallmarks to the MINI’s famous predecessor. It’s bigger in every dimension, but at just over eleven feet long it’s still petite for a modern car, at least in the United States. Fully open both doors and the MINI is wider than it is long. The hood opens clamshell-style, taking the headlights with it, resulting in a nose that’s free of seams. This quiet elegance is carried through the design; the windows are frameless, the fenders slightly flared, and the windows seem to be continuous from windshield to backlight. Even if you don’t like hatchbacks, there’s something timelessly cool about the MINI’s tough but compact shape. Cooler yet, the roof and mirrors can be ordered in contrasting black or white as well as body color at no additional cost. The MINI offers a 12-color palette and a choice of cute hood stripes, too. My blue and white test car had hotel valets sprinting for the privilege of parking it.
Inside, the MINI’s art-house look continues. The first thing to catch the eye is the speedometer, which is mounted dead center and about the size of a dinner plate. A smaller tachometer rides atop the steering column. Chrome aircraft-style toggle switches for the windows and a nice fat ball of a shifter are retro touches. They’re balanced by much more futuristic, spaceship-ovoid turn signal stalks and minimalist door panels. The MINI makes a great travel/commute companion for one or two people only. There’s seating for four inside the MINI, but do your best to win the coin toss to ride up front as the rear seat legroom leaves something to be desired. Cockpit storage and luggage space are also at a serious premium. Apart from the lack of space, which should be pretty obvious considering the petite exterior, there’s only one real downside to the inside; it looks cool, but the some of plastic feels toylike and cheap. I could complain about the placement of the dead pedal, too, but I won’t.
Why complain? It’s academic. Turn the key, and comfort and ergonomics will soon be forgotten. The MINI practically redefines the concept of “fun to drive.” Thanks to a “Z-link” multi-link rear axle borrowed from BMW and MacPherson struts up front, the MINI drives like no economy car you’ve ever met. It is equally happy playing econobox commuter or hot rod, and that’s the idea, of course. My test MINI was the “base” Cooper model, and it was happy to run rings around anything in its class, including the more powerful Ford Focus SVT and Toyota Celica. It even felt happier over our curvy, hilly test loop than even some dedicated sports cars like the Audi TT. With the wheels pushed out to the corners and grippy 15″ wheels, the flyweight Mini’s responses are almost telepathic. The ride is a bit stiffer than the average economy car, but not so harsh as to be uncomfortable, and the nimble handling is a huge payoff. Assisting the nut behind the wheel are standard anti-lock brakes with Electronic Braking Distribution (EBD) and Cornering Brake Control (CBC), a system which counteracts rear-end looseness when braking through turns.
The MINI is eager to chirp the tires when launching, so it’s a surprise to learn that it’s only got 115 horsepower to work with. The 1.6 liter four-cylinder makes the most of its 110 foot-pounds of torque throughout the powerband. Just between you and me, there’s enough power to cruise easily at ridiculous speeds. Better yet, it returns 28/37 mileage, even when driven in anger. On road trips, the MINI’s 13-gallon tank means that there aren’t many fuel stops to interrupt the fun. I never found myself wishing for more grunt, but it’s available in the form of the 163-horse supercharged MINI Cooper S. The standard five-speed manual transmission is quick and smooth, well-suited to aggressive driving. A continuously variable transmission is offered, but would take much of the fun out of driving the MINI.
BMW calls the MINI a “premium compact.” That means that in addition to the cute-as-a-button looks and slick interior, you get six standard airbags, a flat tire monitor, and a CD player . The options list includes stability control, a spoiler, a full-length panoramic sunroof, rain sensing wipers, heated seats, a reverse parking aid, automatic climate control, a navigation system, a choice of sound systems…in short, it’s easy to outfit the MINI just like a seven-eighths scale luxury car. Sticking to the basics will net a shocking pricetag, though. MINIs start at $16,425, and our test car stickered for just $17,250. But you’ll have to find your own; this one is mine. They won’t get this test car from me until they pry it from my…you know the rest.
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2003 MINI Cooper, which we tested.
Length: 142.8 in
Width: 66.5 in.
Height: 55.4 in.
Wheelbase: 97.1 in.
Curb weight: 2524 lb
Cargo space: 5.3 cu.ft. (seats up); 23.7 cu.ft (seats folded)
Base price: $16,425
Price as tested: $17,250
Engine: 1.6 liter SOHC inline four-cylinder
Drivetrain: five-speed manual, front-wheel drive
Horsepower: 115 @ 6000
Torque: 110 @ 4500
Fuel capacity: 13 gal.
Est. mileage: 28/37


