Automotive Reviews
Archived
Back-catalog of reviews written before 2008.
2001 Ford Windstar
Jun 22nd
The Ford Windstar is the only of the Big Three’s minivans with only one permutation. Chrysler’s various minis are available as two different brands, with two different lengths. General Motors also produces similar minivans under three different imprints, in two lengths. But the Windstar stands alone. There’s no Mercury or Lincoln version, and no short-wheelbase model, either. The other two minivans sold under Ford’s umbrella, the Mazda MPV and Mercury Villager, are on completely different platforms.
That’s both good and bad. It’s good because it means that there are no shared flaws between these vehicles. For instance, if you don’t like the seating position in a Chevrolet Venture but want to buy from GM, you’re out of luck; the Pontiac Montana and Oldsmobile Silhouette share the same basic layout. Buyers who aren’t happy with the Villager might like the Windstar just fine. On the other hand, it’s been a while since the Windstar’s last major overhaul. The competition at Chrysler, GM, Honda and Toyota is all newer, and it shows.
That’s not to say Ford’s been ignoring the Windstar, of course. There are styling tweaks for 2001, as well as a tire pressure monitoring system and “smart” airbags which adjust their deployment depending on seat position, seatbelt use, and other factors.
The design is familiar, with its nicely proportioned nose, triangular headlamps, and chrome eggcrate grille like that of Ford’s trucks. The Windstar can be dressed down for the plain-Jane LX model, given a hint of sportiness with the SE Sport package which includes a blacked-out grille and five-spoke wheels, or dressed up with the high-chrome, two-toned Limited model. The Windstar’s 3.8 liter V6 nets Ultra Low Emissions Vehicle (ULEV) status for the minivan, and still makes 200 horsepower. That’s pretty impressive for an “old” overhead-valve design. The four-speed automatic transmission benefits from a much-needed improvement in smoothness and shift quality. With the optional towing package the Windstar can pull up to 3500 pounds.
Like the Toyota Sienna, the Windstar feels heavy and solid on the road. Also like the Sienna, it’s highly rated for safety in federal crash-tests. Dual-stage airbags and the aforementioned “smart” airbag system go along way toward this achievement. Standard antilock brakes and optional traction control and side airbags make the Windstar an even more compelling option for family safety. An interactive yaw control system will be added during 2001 as well.
The Windstar has a 26-gallon fuel tank and a 500-mile freeway cruising range. Ford clearly had traveling in mind when this van was designed. The optional Autovision entertainment center helps to keep parents sane while racking up those miles, with a 6.4-inch color monitor and a removable videocassette player. Headphones are also included. Luckily, the Windstar is also a comfortable car to drive. The chair-height seats are comfortable enough for hours of driving, and the long dashboard doesn’t glare on inside of the windshield. Dual power sliding doors are commonplace on minvans these days; the optional adjustable accelerator and brake pedals are anything but. Ford’s handy innovation (first seen on the Taurus and F-Series pickups) has yet to catch on with other manufacturers. Other Windstar surprise-and-delight features include mirror-mounted turn signals, optional heated seats and an obstacle-detecting system for backing up.
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2001 Ford Windstar SEL.
Length: 200.9 in.
Width: 75.2 in.
Height: 68.2 in.
Wheelbase: 120.7 in.
Curb weight: 4296 lb.
Cargo space: 136.4 cu.ft. (four-door, all seats removed)
Towing capacity: 3500 lb. (with towing package)
Engine: 3.8 liter OHV V6
Drivetrain: four-speed automatic, front wheel drive
Horsepower: 200 @ 4900
Torque: 240 @ 3600
Fuel capacity: 26 gal.
Fuel economy: 18/23
2002 Lexus ES300
Jun 21st
If you like the sublimely decadent Lexus LS430, but aren’t so excited about its titanic proportions and fuel consumption, chances are you’ll feel right at home in the all-new 2002 Lexus ES300.
Somehow, the Lexus ES300 has always seemed like the “cheap” Lexus. Even after the introduction of the smaller, less expensive IS300, the ES300 seemed to occupy a niche below it in the pecking order, perhaps because of a distant but still obvious relationship to the bread-and-butter Toyota Camry. The ES300 was never actually a cheap car, but it suffered in comparison to its more unique stablemates, in much the same way that the Infiniti I30 seems less special because of its close relationship with its cousin the Nissan Maxima. That’s all changed for 2002, however, as the ES300 gets a much-overdue update (it had been basically the same car for a decade) and steps off in a completely new direction.
With the IS300 available to cater to the sport-luxury market, the all-new ES300 abandons any pretense of sporting intent. It’s longer and taller than last year’s model, and numerous improvements to the body structure make it a quieter, more luxurious vehicle.
The new design molds elements of the Lexus SC430 and Toyota Celica into a unique, distinctive look. The triangular headlights are pulled back far along the front fenders, and the hood has a deep dip. The frameless, horizontal-bar grille is a Lexus hallmark. It has a tallish stance, for improved headroom, and the C-pillar curves in a graceful, high-flanks arc similar to that of the Lexus GS430. The 16″ wheels are unfortunately ordinary. Taillights are spruced up with a sweep of chrome.
Pampering is the name of the game inside. The seats are instantly pleasing and couch-like. The very handsome interior features California walnut trim accentuating a T-shaped console. Little touches like footwell lights and water-repellent front side glass (it’s coated with titanium silicate, which makes water bead more easily) set the ES300 apart from the near-luxury crowd. The optional navigation system lives high in the dash, and the screen tilts to reduce glare. A touch of a button slides the whole screen out of the way for loading of compact discs or cassettes into the audio system. A high-end, high-quality Mark Levinson sound system is also available.
As the “300″ in the name suggests, the ES300 is powered by a 3.0 liter V6. This double overhead cam motor puts out 210 horsepower and powers smoothly down the freeway and away from traffic lights thanks to Variable Valve Timing with intelligence (VVT-i). Most impressive about this motor is its high (for a V6) fuel economy of 21/29, and its Ultra Low Emissions Vehicle (ULEV) rating. It’s mated to a five-speed automatic transmission. The additional gear’s purpose is also keeping things smooth on the freeway.
The four-wheel independent suspension is supple and isolated, but not numb. MacPherson struts are used at all four corners, giving the ES300 a smooth highway ride. It comes close to matching the LS430′s magic-carpet feel, and it’s a definite cut above the competition from Infiniti. The ES300 isn’t afraid of curvy roads, either. Spirited driving is not this car’s mission in life, however. It’s less than entertaining on those tight switchbacks, but at least it isn’t scary. An optional Adaptive Variable Suspension (AVS) features “active” shock absorbers which change their damping rate according to road conditions, vehicle speed, and vehicle movement. Drivers can choose between variable levels of damping to make the ride softer or firmer.
Like in big brother LS430, there’s a whole lot of safety-enhancing technology along for the ride. Standard equipment on the new ES300 are anti-lock brakes and Electronic Brake Force Distribution (EBD). EBD redistributes braking power when one or more wheels starts to skid, to maximize braking ability. Vehicle Skid Control (VSC) is optional. It’s an active safety system which uses traction control, EBD, and the brakes to keep the car stable while cornering on slippery roads or during emergency braking. Side curtain airbags are standard, as are dual-stage front airbags.
One of the nicer things about the ES300 is that it feels slightly more expensive than it is, thanks in part to the optional equipment it’s inherited from the LS430. The six-disc CD changer and DVD navigation system are all but taken for granted in luxury cars these days. Want a rear sunshade? It’s on the list. Dual-level heated seats? Got ‘em. High-intensity discharge headlamps and rain-sensing windshield wipers? Yes, sir, coming right up. And don’t forget all the add-ons previously mentioned, like the adjustable suspension and stability control. Pricing is expected to begin in the low $30,000 range–right in line with the rest of the market. Ed Laukes of Lexus sums it up nicely when he says, “Call it a baby LS430.”
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2002 Lexus ES300, which we tested.
Length: 191,1 in.
Width: 71.3 in.
Height: 57.3 in.
Wheelbase: 107.1 in.
Curb weight: 3439 lb
Cargo space: 14.5 cu.ft.
Engine: 3,0 liter, 24-valve DOHC V6
Drivetrain: five-speed automatic, front-wheel drive
Horsepower: 210 @ 5800
Torque: 220 @ 4400
Fuel capacity: 18.5 gal.
Est. mileage: 21/29
2001 Porsche Boxster S
Jun 21st
It’s often said that Porsches have dual natures. They’re equally happy cutting apexes on a race track or getting groceries. Actually, that’s a slight misstatement. Porsches are capable of performing mundane car tasks, unlike many other sports cars. They’re not really happy unless they’re on an honest-to-goodness race track, however.
Case in point; the 2001 Porsche Boxster S. The Boxster joined the Porsche lineup when demand for a less-expensive junior model collided with the desire to produce a true mid-engined Porsche for the street, and resulted in a popular show car. High customer demand urged Porsche to create a roadgoing version, and the Boxster has become as respected a member of the lineup as the venerable 911. In 2000 the S model hit the streets, with a larger 3.2 liter, 250 horsepower engine to up the performance ante.
Without a doubt it looks the part of junior Porsche. The tubby, pinched-ended silhouette is reminiscent of both the contemporary 911 and the classic 550 Spyder, a racing Porsche from the Fifties. The aerodynamically tapered body is pulled down tight over 17″ wheels (the rear wheels are wider than the fronts, race-car style), through which the bright red brake calipers are visible. The Boxster’s style is all designed to hint at or show off the substance lying beneath. Big air intakes on the flanks aren’t just for show; they feed cool air to the engine. No showy spoilers for this car, either; air is managed by a small, discreed spoiler which retracts at speeds below 50 mph. The Boxster S has a third radiator for additional cooling as well, resulting in a slightly different front fascia.
It’s purposeful inside as well. The Boxster’s oval body shape is echoed in the contours of the dash and cockpit. Driving a Porsche is a very oval experience. Most of the touchable surfaces in the cabin car covered with “soft-touch” material–a special grain for the leather or plastic which gives the interior a surprisingly warm, friendly feeling. All Boxsters are convertibles, and the roll bars behind the seats are a visible part of the structure. The power-operated top lowers in less than a quarter minute. A hardtop is available, as is a cool roof rack that can be attached to either the hard or the soft top and can carry up to 165 pounds of bikes, skis, or other sporting equipment. The Boxster S is set apart from lesser Boxsters by a unique gauges and aluminum trim.
We were surprised by the first Boxster S we drove. After hearing all about Porsche’s engine and chassis development, we found the Boxster to be a sluggish, pouty companion around town. The high doorsills and roll hoop behind the seats give it an unpleasant bathtub feel, and the controls are heavy. Leaving stoplights with no lurching as the clutch is released takes some practice. The horizontally-opposed (“boxer”) six-cylinder engine burbling away right behind the passenger cabin provides adequate power, but feels unpleasantly restrained, as if something has been stuffed into the tailpipe. The six-speed manual transmission is shared with the 911 Carrera and shifts nicely, but all in all the car is sulky around town. It will handle commuting duty, grudgingly.
Then we got it on a racetrack. Given a chance to run, the Boxster was transformed. With nothing but open track ahead, the boxer motor shakes off the lethargy, 250 horsepower makes itself known, and the 2855-lb car rockets eagerly from turn to turn. The Boxster can be heel-toe downshifted just like a race car, and enjoys the opportunity to let you practice. The heavy-feeling steering is perfectly weighted for track time as well. The Boxster has a mid-engined layout, considered by many the best for racing. The inherent balance of the mid-engine layout results in quick turn-in and hair-trigger reactions from the four-wheel independent suspension. The suspension is a bit stiff on the road, but on the track it turns the Boxster into an extension of your driving.
Also invisible on the road is the new-for-2001 Porsche Stability Management (PSM) system. This system replaces the more conventional traction control on the options list, and detects slippage at the front or rear. The system uses the brakes and throttle control to stabilize the car on any surface. We didn’t notice it on the road, but on the track it kept us going straight when we pushed a bit beyond our ability more than once. It can be switched off, but even the most overconfident drivers will appreciate having the discreet assistance of PSM along.
Around town we didn’t even notice the massive four-wheel disc brakes, which haul the Boxtster to a stop phenomenally fast but are still best for street duty; they began to smoke and smell after an hour or two of lead-foot hot laps. That aside, it was instantly clear to us that no Boxster will be truly happy without a race track or a winding canyon road to tear up on a regular basis. Buyers wanting a Porsche as an ego boost will be more comfortable in the larger, pricier 911 on a daily basis. True car nuts, on the other hand, will be happy to cram 9.1 cubic feet of luggage into the Boxster’s tiny cargo areas and head for the hills for a weekend.
Specifications:
All specs are for the 2001 Porsche Boxster S, which we tested.
Length: 171.0 in.
Width: 70.1 in.
Height: 50.8 in.
Wheelbase: 95.2 in.
Curb weight: 2855 lb.
Cargo space: 9.1 cu.ft.
Base price: $50,200
Price as tested: $56,122
Engine: 3.2 liter, DOHC “boxer” six-cylinder
Drivetrain: six-speed manual, rear-wheel drive
Horsepower: 250 @ 6250
Torque: 225 @ 4500
Fuel capacity: 16.9 gal.
Est. mileage: 18/26


